MANIFESTO

#63

CHANGE OF SPACE

Poor Things

2024.01.25

Text by Chiara Belardi

A female perspective, the creation of a new world, and an intriguing exploration of social and linguistic dynamics shaping perceptions of reality. Poor Things serves as a parable on the excercise of power while simultaneously offering a unique journey into adulthood.

Yorgos Lanthimos’s latest film, Poor Things, delves into stories of men grappling with issues of love, hate, and dependence on women. Based on Alasdair Gray’s novel, which unveils extraordinary lives through a doctor’s diary, including that of Bella Baxter. This feminist creation, masterfully explored by Emma Stone, stands out for its narrative strength and coherence, extending beyond reflections on the intellectual and moral freedom of the protagonist. Set in a fantasy and steampunk world around 1890, the film follows Bella’s story, resurrected by a mad doctor and facing life without gender biases, as her mind retains the innocence of a child, untouched by societal conditioning. Director Yorgos Lanthimos describes it as a surprising work, a parable on power, and a unique coming of age story illustrating Bella’s rapid evolution. Emma Stone’s extraordinary portrayal captures Bella’s unique growth as the film explores themes of gender identity and freedom. Poor Things excels in portraying the precise transition of a child within an adult body. The plot reveals Bella as the result of an experiment, with the brain of an unborn child transplanted into the body of a deceased woman, creating a paradox of an adult body with a developing mind. This hybrid creation presents the paradox of an adult body with a still-developing mind. From a primary state, Bella does not yet seem fully a woman, as she has not gone through the process of subjectification that defines gender identity.

Emma Stone in POOR THINGS. Photo by Yorgos Lanthimos, Courtesy of Searchlight Pictures. © 2023 Searchlight Pictures All Rights Reserved.

Bella is a special character within a story that is absolutely amazing to me. When I read the novel, I immediately thought Bella would be the driving force behind a film, as everything is told from her point of view. She is a woman who goes out into the world with the opportunity to have her experiences on her own terms, shaping her personality without submitting to the conventions and rules of society, family or caste.

 – Yorgos Lanthimos

Emma Stone in POOR THINGS. Photo by Atsushi Nishijima. Courtesy of Searchlight Pictures. © 2023 Searchlight Pictures All Rights Reserved.

The story is based on Judith Butler’s theory in the text Bodies That Matter, emphasizing how social norms influence the process of subjectification. In Bella’s world, gender assignments and expectations are present from birth, influencing her path of growth and development. For Lanthimos, this is a discourse that starts from afar, as all the male figures in his cinema are nothing but negative, from the jailer father of Dogtooth to the useless men of The Lobster and The Favorite. In contrast, strong women, such as Nicole Kidman, a mother and wife willing to do anything to save children and appearances in Sacrifice of the Sacred Deer. Mark Ruffalo as a shady lawyer, Willem Dafoe as a mad scientist, and the talented Ramy Youssef as an enamored doctor create a clever simplification of the Greek director’s world, presented in the form of a satirical fable. The film challenges mainstream cinema with forbidden elements, starting with sexual liberation.

Emma Stone in POOR THINGS. Courtesy of Searchlight Pictures. © 2023 Searchlight Pictures All Rights Reserved.

From the start, it’s clear that Bella’s hybrid body is the result of an experiment by God (Willem Dafoe), the peculiar and somewhat unsettling surgeon who enjoys atypical procedures on bodies, playfully referencing experimental practices aimed at creating new forms of life. The film addresses the issue of language and norms influencing the act of naming, highlighting a narrative about language itself and how it shapes social expectations from birth, based on assigned gender. Poor Things is an intriguing exploration not only of Bella’s story but also of the social and linguistic dynamics shaping our gender perceptions. It represents a rebellion against the narrative archetype where heroines are condemned to death and unhappiness by male characters. Yorgos Lanthimos overlays Bella onto various male archetypes, transforming their meaning. Bella becomes a mad element altering the formula of situations, challenging predictable conclusions. Thus, Bella, with her remarkable hair growth and the ability to learn fifteen new words every twenty-four hours, temporarily confines herself to exploring her internal world, discovering pleasure. However, societal norms and beliefs impose restrictions on her natural exploration. This conflict becomes the centerpiece of the narrative about the liberation of the female figure, highlighting how sexuality, understood as power, domination, blackmail and the conventions imposed by gender roles, perpetuated over centuries by repressive upbringings and rules, deprive women of control over their bodies and freedom of self-determination. Sexuality then becomes a tool of rebellion, challenging the norms that seek to restrict and control female autonomy.

Stone’s ability to become, in those scenes, precisely what she is in the story, namely a little girl moving inside a woman’s body is phenomenal. Hers are not the mechanical motions of a doll but the awkward but entirely human ones of a creature who is learning to gauge her balance in space and how her body keeps her balanced.

Courtesy of images by Searchlight Pictures.
Courtesy of images by Searchlight Pictures.
Courtesy of images by Searchlight Pictures.
Courtesy of images by Searchlight Pictures.
(From L-R:) Margaret Qualley, Willem Dafoe and Ramy Youssef in POOR THINGS. Photo by Yorgos Lanthimos. Courtesy of Searchlight Pictures. © 2023 20th Century Studios All Rights Reserved.
Creative freedom

2024.02.28

A collection that rethinks the concept of fashion as a manifestation of power and full representation of creativity, investigating the historical legacy and future of femininity. The looks in Dior’s FW24 collection convey the radiant power of a pluralistic, autonomous and versatile femininity, reactivating that key moment of creative freedom of which Miss Dior is the emblem.

CULTURE

ANNIE ERNAUX AND PHOTOGRAPHY

2024.02.28

In Exteriors (Journal du dehors), Annie Ernaux immerses herself in the interactions at the margins of daily life. Her words become the focal point of a visual reflection unfolding through a selection of images from the MEP collection in Paris. These photographs merge with Ernaux’s text, creating a social and political narrative.

NEWS

We Are Not Going Back

2024.02.27

The new single released by Wolfgang Tillmans is accompanied by a video directed by Tillmans himself, using 80 years old footage by his grandfather Karl R. Tillmans filmed in New York 1939 and Western Germany 1949.

PARIS

TRANSPARENCIES

2024.02.27

Tulle, velvet, organza, and chiffon; the clues to a journey through the twenty-first century sexual revolution under the gaze of the Couturier who left his mark on an era. The new exhibition at the Yves Saint Laurent museum in Paris reconstructs the iconic textile innovation of the 1960s made by Yves and more.

COLLECTION

SPIRIT

2024.02.25

The Fall Winter 2024 collection by Maximilian Davis is an interpretation of the 1920s through a modern lens, particularly inspiring as it offers a new perspective on the elegance and rebellion of that era.